Review: ‘Vikings,’ Season 4, Episode 1, ‘A Good Treason’

Many, many days after the premiere of this season, an exotic foreign vacation, and painless acclimating to reality later, it is time, my friends, it is time.


So, what you’re telling us is that you’re finally going to stop being lazy and get down to the nitty-gritty?


Woah woah woah, let’s not get carried away – I had obligations to attend to, I had things to do. But, yes. Basically. I have actually budgeted time to do this, I have blocked out part of my schedule to get this review schtick goin’, I have a load of laundry in the washing machine, I have snacks in hand, and all of this means that I am ready to watch some brutal Vikings ridiculousness.




Though, I suppose I should reiterate that, between seasons, I don’t actually watch the previous season(s), meaning that if there are inconsistencies that I miss, character developments I have forgotten, or loopholes that I have embellished since watching it last, it is on me completely and I am more than happy to eat crow whenever someone points it out to me. Luckily, I know that you guys will always keep me on track in the comments!


Why not? Wait, don’t tell me. You couldn’t make time to rewatch Vikings because there are too many British murder mysteries to watch on Netflix.


Bingo. I may be on season 16 of one of them, but I refuse to be affected negatively by your judgment. Needless to say, I am more than thankful for the 30-second recap at the start of every new season. That’s basically all I need to remember, right? No? Well. Anyway.


Here we are. And let’s get to it!


We start this season off with a not-mortally wounded Ragnar (Travis Fimmel) riding a noble steed through a rocky, vegetated landscape. Considering the aforementioned not-mortally wounded state of him as he squints meaningfully at the hills, I would venture to say that this is indeed a dream and with any luck there will be strange hallucinations of dead friends and – if we get lucky – a message from the gods. As Ragnar nears his destination (instead of the pearly gates, it is a door into the dining hall of Valhalla, replete with the sound of laughter and clinking cups), the doors begin to close and before his eyes are the bloodied and bruised forms of his loved ones at various points of the show, some by his hand, others by their own. It’s kind of a dick move by the gods, but I assume the message is bro, your time isn’t nowCome back later.


I’m sure that’s the exact vernacular of Valhalla’s occupants.


Oh, 100%.


Meanwhile, we cut to Aslaug (Alyssa Sutherland) wandering through the woods until she tracks down the Oracle (John Kavanagh), asking him about the distribution of power in the event of Ragnar’s death. She’s dressed in dark clothing and bathed in pretty severe lighting, which automatically says to me that they’re going to completely undo any of the compassion that they had built for her in the last few seasons and replace it with a villain plot, but, maybe I just have too little faith in how the writers tie in villainous arches without it feeling hamfisted and obvious, or in the worst case, completely random (see: my ex-fave shipbuilder with flawless MAC-makeup artist applied eyeliner). I would be happy to be proven wrong.


Anyway, the Oracle remains mum about the who sitch for the most part – while he confirms that he has seen a woman ruling Kattegat, he does not confirm that it is Aslaug bedecked in the ruling furs. “The gods are watching,” he warns. She seems as unflappable as ever with a Regina George-worthy look that says, simply, duh.


Would you really be surprised if they went full-villain with her, though?


Not at all. This show has (in a word) interesting relationships with the women in it in general, but Aslaug has had a target on her back since scene one.


Back in Kattegat, Ragnar’s kids have grown significantly since we last saw them, playing with one-another on the recognizable decks of the once-nondescript fishing town. Bjorn (Alexander Ludwig) enters and embraces the four boys, indicating that the troop is nearly home and they have been gone for a long while, so long, in fact, that Bjorn’s daughter with Thorunn is nearly a toddler. Oh, don’t remember that subplot? You don’t remember the shieldmaiden that was wounded in battle and then suddenly very concerned about how she looked, despite battle scars being revered in things like warriors in their culture? You don’t remember how she bemoaned not being physically attractive to Bjorn, despite him giving absolutely no indication that he had lost his attraction to her, that she ran away because suddenly her worth was not as a fighter and being beside him in battle, but being a perfect sexual object and she had failed because she wasn’t supermodel pretty anymore?


Nope, I don’t remember that garbage, either.


You seem bitter, dude. If this were a commercial, I’d tell you to eat a Snickers.


I have a lot of feelings about that plot, still. Anyway, she left their kid behind. As it is a daughter, Bjorn gives it a look that can only be described as :/ – understandably, Aslaug is offended by the rebuff of his own child, despite probably knowing it was going to happen, and assures him that they’ll be taking care of her. A+ Bjorn, way to not even ask what the kiddo’s name is.


Ragnar has been put to rest in his room, comatose and obviously not as mobile as dream-Ragnar. Floki (Gustaf Skarsgård) approaches sullenly and places carved runes on Ragnar’s chest, telling him that they will help to heal him and the imagery is so strikingly sad, like when my dog knows that he shouldn’t have eaten that roll of toilet paper, did anyway, and knows that I found the mangled roll but is sorry, so sorry, that it makes a part of my heart hurt even though both of them are kind of shitty people.


Later, after the spoils of war have been shown to Aslaug, they hold a pseudo community meeting to talk about their intense gains. In lieu of his father being an intense sneeze away from death, Bjorn helms the meeting, toting their successes to familiar faces in the crowd and the township as a whole. Straight up, he lacks the innate charisma of his father, but he tries to work the crowd the best he can, until…




Well, then he kind of blows it. He has Floki publicly arrested for the murder of Athelstan.


Huh. Well, if we know anything about Ragnar, he simply loves when people do things for him.


Yeah, I totally don’t see this backfiring.


So! Floki has been outed as Athelstan’s killer and has been arrested, he is subsequently tied to a pole in the middle of town and has food and rocks hurled at him. Nothing kills an ego quite like public humiliation. Later, it is hard to watch as Floki and Helga’s (Maude Hirst) little one Angrboða feed her father bits of food while he is chained and paraded. He begs for Helga to help him escape, even if he (surely, must) know that to do so will put her and their child in a grave situation. I have always loved Helga, it is hard for me to see her in such a situation. Please be kind to her tender souls, show, please please please.


In Hedeby, Kalf (Ben Robson), Lagertha (Katheryn Winnick), and the remains of their soldiers return with war stories and mad swag. We’re reminded of the continuing existence of Einar (joy), Erlendur (why??) and the fact that the humorless Kalf (ugh) are still being portrayed as threats to Lagertha’s legacy, as if she isn’t 1) one of the most beloved members of the show, 2) fierce as fuck, and 3) capable of shanking a bitch in the gut and still retaining the good fortune of everyone in Hedeby. Anyway, he basically promotes Lagertha to co-captain of the ship and allows her to split the earldom with him, even though the two of them are not married.


I don’t care how much the writers try to convince us of Kalf’s amazing ways or how he’s even near the level that is Lagertha, dude has the personality of a soggy white bread loaf. Not buying it, have never bought it, will never go to the store to get it.


N e x t.


Back in Kattegat, the townspeople welcome the arrival of your friendly neighborhood slave traders. Aslaug approaches a woman of Asian descent after some consideration and seems to be even more intrigued when she defiantly dislodges her chin from Aslaug’s imploring fingers. Stay tuned, dollars to doughnuts, that woman will be some kind of plot point.


They really, really lay it on thick when they want to.


In other news, Ragnar finally stirs. One of his sons (who? I don’t remember, they all kind of run together. Ubbe? Maybe?) discovers that he is awake, fetches Ragnar some ale (evidently, that’s the easiest way to cement your pathway to becoming king – nailed it), and tells Aslaug that Ragnar, the king, has woken up.


Later, when he arrives at the dining hall, it is met with fanfare and excitement, even if he assumes Aslaug’s lackluster reception of him rudely enough, quickly turning his attention to the former slave, now new Aslaug handmaiden from earlier (would that be the correct terminology?), confirming the flippant and predictable this person will be important guess from earlier. How likely is it that Ragnar is going to impregnate her? Survey says: he’s going to give it his earnest college try.


Luckily, Ragnar’s caddish tendencies, easily ranked as my least favorite of his, as I think it detracts from him as a character and as a whole, are quickly cut short by the chastisement he lays thick on Bjorn for making the executive decision to imprison Floki without his father’s say in it. He lays this gem on his son:


“Did you also think that if I wanted him arrested I would have done it a long time ago. Now you have made it public and left me with no options. Now I am forced to deal with my errant friend.”


Brutal, dude.


I feel bad for Bjorn, in a way. He’s honestly just trying to impress his father, it’s practically a timeworn tradition in society to do so.


Sure, I’ll give you that. But there is a difference between getting a good job, buying an awesome car, and picking up a mutual hobby because you heard your father mention it once and you want him to be impressed with your good tastes, your financial successes, as well as be able to talk to him about the varied array of bird calls native to Britain, and imprisoning his friend and also leaving his brother behind in a foreign country.


Oh, didn’t you hear? Rollo (Clive Standen) is still in Paris, which I am sure is going very, very well and is not at all an awkward transition.


Cut to him, and I am sure we have never seen a more telling rendition of Bull In A China Shop. Also, this has got to be one of the most depressing weddings I have ever seen on television. Listen, I think Princess Gisla is as interesting as an empty bag of potato chips, but even I feel a little bit bad for her as her father forces her head down while she is wedding this hulking stranger. My only hope is that the forthcoming exposure we have to her as this season goes on fleshes her out in a positive way and doesn’t turn Paris into Wessex 2.0, because I would honestly love if Rollo had a solid character in his life (other than Ragnar) that could help keep his characterization consistent for a millisecond. Am I shipping Gisla and Rollo? Gislo? Risla? Rosla? Gillo?


Way, way too early to tell. But I am going to give it a shot, if only because there is nothing sadder than a reluctant bride crying on her wedding day while doing the bidding of her clinically wimpish father. Rollo has gone through so many transformations through the show that it is possible to get whiplash going through them all, but it was hard not to see the bemused respect he had for her when she was the epitome of an ice cube queen in their ceremonial chamber, the humor he had when she pulled a knife out and threatened him, the way he fell asleep without a singular hint of ravishing the aloof, virginal princess. The potential for angst is huge and if there are shades of historical romance in this show that turns the ridiculous plot devices to 11, I may just buckle in for the ride. The more I think about it, the more I need it.


Anyway, so Rollo was left in Paris and got married to a princess. That is without a doubt not something I thought I would type back in season 1. Bonus! He has seemingly lost some of his rape-ier tendencies. Let’s hope it stays that way.


You aren’t going to mention how you actually, legitimately, pressed pause when Rollo was standing shirtless in the bedchamber?


Honestly, I just assumed that’s what everyone did at that scene. Am I wrong? Oh.


Back in Hedeby, Kalf gathers everyone together and basically says “actually, jk~” about allowing Lagertha to be co-earl with him, urged on by Einar, earlier, who basically told Kalf to put the kabbash on the whole thing and cut the bullshit, because Lagertha liked him more. Which?? Ok?? I mean, Einar, dude, you really suck. Lagertha – despite all of the bed partners in this show that have tried desperately to prove otherwise – has standards and you didn’t meet them. Move on.


In a remarkably and nearly interesting development, after Kalf leads Einar and his men (the dissedents who aligned with Einar after the agreement between Kalf and Lagertha) to the center of a field, he unloads a barrage of arrows on the lot of them. Seriously, Kalf’s arrows mow them all down with the advanced weaponry he brought back from Paris. Einar ends up with an arrow in his throat and castrated by Lagertha, and, wow, I can’t believe I am saying this, but I actually did not see Kalf going down this route. I can’t think of a more fitting end to a more irritating character.


I will say, he looked a little worried when he saw Lagertha’s expression as she channeled her inner Lorena Bobbit.


And you wouldn’t be? I imagine there are few things that top the boner-killing abilities of seeing a woman, who you are intensely attracted to, satisfied with her castration job while her face is streaked with blood.


Back in Paris, Rollo hears about a Viking camp outside of Paris from Eirik, a man of power in Rollo’s forces left in Frankia, intent on raiding Paris while pledging their still-allegiance to Ragnar. This ends as well as you imagine it would – which is to say, really poorly. Rollo agrees to meet the camp and, like Kalf before him, signals to hidden forces surrounding the area and the Frankish bowmen kill every Viking man, woman, and child in the vicinity.


Rollo is warned by Eirik that Ragnar will avenge them and that his betrayal will not end well.


Huh, contrary to the sentiment you had earlier, I feel like you type some variation of that phrase every season. 


I am pretty sure I do.


In Kattegat, Bjorn meets with Ragnar to tell him that he is going away. He isn’t going to find Thorunn or anything like that, he is going “out in the wilderness, away from everything, [to] find out [if he] could survive.” This is basically the Vikings version of an early-20s dude backpacking around Europe to find his spiritual energy, but with a bit more death and murder. Ragnar has hints of tenderness as he looks at his son, despite of the headache it has all turned into, and you can’t help but wonder what is going on inside of his head. He has to know that his son really does need to get his ducks in a line if he will ever become a ruler in his own right, but he also has to know that he may lose him in the process.


The way Ragnar tells Bjorn “prove me wrong” has GOT to be one of the most savage parts of this episode. My heart dropped for poor, clumsy, inelegant Bjorn in that moment. I hope he proves us all wrong.


And then, of course, that leaves his inevitable confrontation with Floki. The conversation is as tense as one would expect it to be, raising all the flags one needs to have to know that this season will be a trial for them both if they make it to the end. “Are you going to kill me?” Floki asks and it is met with Ragnar’s typical ambiguity, answering neither yes or no, instead showing anger – nah, that’s not right – disappointment at the actions of his friend, at the fact that they’re now where they’re at because of them.



And with that, episode 1 is complete.


What are your general thoughts?


As a first episode of any season, this episode was all about resolving some loose ends while unweaving another massive crocheted blanket. We had some follow-up on plots from last season, which is great, but we also had a lot of hints towards future tensions, the problems that will come, and what we have in store. All-in-all, it felt strong, though I hope they steer clear from some of the more cliched plot devices that they have used in the past.


Last season ended on a pretty rough note for me, and as a whole had many twists and turns that I found either egregiously dull or painfully obvious. The way things are setting up promises a fourth season that will be, at the very least, entertaining. I am excited to see where everyone will go from here and I eagerly await the character development that has already been hinted at in the first episode.


How about an arbitrary rating before you go?


Certainly! Simply put, I give this episode five surprise crossbow ambushes out of six.


How did you all feel about this episode?

11 thoughts on “Review: ‘Vikings,’ Season 4, Episode 1, ‘A Good Treason’

  1. I was hoping for more. Can’t say exactly what more, but more. Regardless I will continue to love Rollo and follow him where e’re he goes. I’m ahead of you so I know where he’s going, which is to say, yeah, even then I’m a true believer.
    Ragnar has fallen down the rabbit hole, not in a good way. Are the writers trying to destroy the character? Character assassination? Floki is flat out insane. Bjorn is growing on me – I especially like his hulking ways and the way Ubba walks just like him. But I do wonder about Siggy- poor little Siggy.
    AND I’m sorry but WTF? A ‘Chinese’ slave? Cannot suspend disbelief.
    Aslaug is dead to me – dead to me I tells ya! Never liked her anyway.
    Lagertha? Please give her more to do.
    I’ll close with this – the show needs Athelstan. Flat out needs Athelstan to humanize the Northmen (because they were only known as Vikings when they were going a-viking) which the writers are turning into flat out brutes. Hard to cheer for brutes.

  2. And the mists parts on a new season of Shanbanana™ brand reviews, just slightly delayed this time, but hey, that just means less waiting time until season 4b rolls around. Even though we might have watched five episodes by now, it always fun to relive the previous episodes through your reviews. I can’t be the only one who come back here and read through the old seasons reviews from time to time right?

    To keep my own memory fresh, I actually rewatched the ep before writing this comment.

    Since I usually start with some Extended Edition info I think I’ll keep doing that. Extended version added another 3 minutes. Not having seen the US cut it’s a little hard to guess what was lost, but I’ll try. Some flavor/extended character stuff. A short farewell between Lagertha and Bjorn before they arrive in Hedeby, a scene of Helga trying to stop Kattegat’s kids from throwing muck at Floki, the wanderer that acted as Rollo’s interpreted not wanting to stay around. And maybe Aslaug getting huffy when one of the boys says Bjorn is teaching him how to fight. Aslaug huffs that her father was a great warrior too, he killed the dragon Fafner and surely she must have passed on some warrior skills.

    The really big scene that was cut though is Bjorn pouring over a crude map of Europe he apparently took in Paris, the owner valuing it more than any gold or jewels. On it is a crude representation of the Mediteranean with Italy in the middle. “It’s my destiny” Bjorn explains to a curious Ubbe. OW! OW! We get it show! Stop swinging that Mallet of Foreshadowing +10

    Otherwise, the major scene every Viking fan cheered for was Einar the Useless becoming Einar the Eunuck. Even though since I’m a member of XY chromosome crowd I’m legally required to at least slightly sympathethically wince. I mean really, haven’t people learned by now. Do NOT try to fuck over Lagertha. All t

    Also, calling Kalf a wet loaf of white bread is so funny and so true. I never liked that douche.

    Alas, poor Helga is going to have a rough couple of episodes.

    Rollo and Gisla are…interesting. Your pausing of shirtless Rollo is totally acceptable. We’re all equally shallow here.

    The Asian slave storyline is a weird one, but I’m sure we’ll come back to, once they’ve gotten some more meat on it’s bones in future episodes.

    Great to have you reviewing again Shannon, looking forward to a crazy 2016, filled with TWICE as many Viking episodes as we usually get. Is it possible to get a Viking overdose? I guess we’ll find out.

  3. “You aren’t going to mention how you actually, legitimately, pressed pause when Rollo was standing shirtless in the bedchamber?

    Honestly, I just assumed that’s what everyone did at that scene. Am I wrong? Oh”

    If you substituted Rollo for Lagertha, that would be spot on for me. Except that all I get to see is her back. 😛

    I can’t really stand the Asian slave subplot. it’s so damn contrived.

    Actually my estimation for Kalf went up a few notches above milquetoast after he and Erlendur arranged the murder of the objectors to Lagertha’s being made a co-earl. And it seems to me that in an indirect way he also solves Lagertha’s problem with dissenters from when she was initially ousted as earl. Whether it was inadvertely or not, I don’t know.

    Erlendur. just ugh. Really UGH. He’s kind of that snarky boy you knew in middle school and wanted to beat the crap out of on the playground just because he’s such a weasel.

  4. I saw such development within Rollo’s character maturation during this episode. His heart broke for Gisla as they were being wed. Seeing her being forcefully carried into their bed chamber made me cringe, but Rollo forcing everyone out and leaving her in peace – made my heart smile. The Rollo scenes saved episode 1 in my humble opinion.

  5. You’re back!! I’ve been creeping this page since episode 1 this season waiting for the reviews 🙂 Glad you had an awesome trip!
    I’m afraid to discuss too much about the season yet because I don’t want to accidentally mix up the episodes and spoil anything for you before you get to see them all. Definitely loved episode 1 though! I agree with your arbitrary rating, though I kinda hoped it would be quantified in “severed packages”… has a nice ring!
    On a side note, I’m a little disturbed. See, I do a lot of messing around on and this past summer I stumbled upon my alleged 33rd great grandfather, Hrólfr Rolf Robert I The Viking Duc De Normandie Ragnvaldsson. Aka Rollo!! No joke. Now I am WELL aware this could be/almost definitely is total BS, I mean how could they really know after so long, but if there is even the remotest chance, is it wrong for me to admire 33rd-gramps’ chiseled abs?? No? If it’s wrong I don’t want to be right.

  6. Oh, also I read somewhere an explanation of how it is ‘supposedly’ plausible that an Asian slave could have ended up in Scandinavia. I forget where, but it had been bugging me too so I googled the character. I guess it kinda helped me suspend disbelief, at least enough to get past it. Still weirdness though.

  7. I thought, when I watched this episode, that it was better than the whole seaonb in season three and I had hope that vikings series 4 would be almost as good as 1 and 2 at least. But all that hitting us over the head with a brick of foreshadowing does really make me heavily sigh. Im glad they have 20 episodes to develop the strop and characters this time around, maybe it won’t seem so plot driven. Plot driven stories really feel empty and pointless to me. What I loved about seasons 1 and 2 was the character driven nature of of the episodes. I still don’t like the way the female characters have become so poorly written in season 3, and even this episode. They are archetypes or ciphers and they were so much more in season one and two. They have to develop people in five places. c catgut, mercia, wessex paris and lagerthas earldom, so i guess they have too many characters to really develop well.. although game of thrones does seem to be able to do this job well. Maybe the problem is only having one writer. No one can write such complexity well alone under such pressure in my opinion. Anyway I am ahead of you by about another four episodes so I can tell you its all better than season 3 which I think was a huge disappointment

    Cheers and so glad you are back… you write the best reviews by umpteen lightyears or a billion viking ships xx Julieanne

  8. Welcome back! Thinking back to episode 1, I have one question (probably rhetorical, but …)
    The Wanderer leaves, Rollo has lost his translator and he can’t talk with the Franks. So how does he communicate sufficiently with the soldiers to organize an attack on the Viking camp? Pantomime? Stick figure sketches?

  9. ha ha Gail, good question! Anyway miss Daffodil, I keep checking back for your next review… bit hungry for your thoughts down here in OZ ( australia) we just finished episode six. Can you have a great big box of popcorn and several nice drinks to hand and do a huge catch up on a rainy day soon??? ( I know I know I am being greedy )

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s